MathBrush
←  All problems

Question P6 Constant total

Today’s problem — free all day, every step. Every day has one.

Cookies — Box A and Box B swap

The ratio of cookies in Box A to cookies in Box B was 5 : 3. After 16 cookies were moved from Box A to Box B, the ratio became 3 : 5. How many cookies were in Box A at first?

See all 7 steps

MathBrush is being tested with a few parent groups, and every solution on the site is open to them — one household, all children. If you were given a code, it goes in once and this device remembers it.

I have a code → See a free one like it

65 worked examples are free without a code, two from every pattern. No account, either way.

About this method

Constant total

Money moves between two people, so their total never changes.

In this one. Both ratios add up to 8 shares, and no cookies entered or left, so the total is the same 8 shares before and after — which forces 1 part (after) to be exactly 1 unit (before), and the 16 cookies to be exactly 2 units.

Before4 shares in allAlithis one movesBenAfter4 shares in allAliBenarrived here

How to spot it

One person gives, sells or loses an amount to the other, and nobody outside the two people gains or loses anything.

Common mistake

Children draw different totals before and after, or forget that moving an amount from one person to the other changes the gap between them by twice that amount.

Practise a similar question

Standard The ratio of Liam's trading cards to Noah's trading cards was 7 : 5. After Liam gave some of his cards to Noah, the ratio became 5 : 7. Together they had 144 cards throughout. How many cards did Liam give to Noah?
All 12 with this pattern →
Get the free patterns and skills booklet

Patterns and skills booklet

Worked examples of all 33 patterns and skills, in a booklet you can print.